This book has the potential to be the most loved or the most hated book since the King James Edition.
It will certainly be as hotly contested and could start or continue arguments that may last a lifetime.
But all of this is nothing new to the baseball fan. Even the first time observer of a game will have an opinion about something and at some time during the game will almost certainly disagree with the umpire or manager regardless of whether they know the difference or even actually saw the play.
That is one of the luxuries of being a baseball fan, you can know a little or you can know a lot but you will always remain at once a novice and an expert. Having an opinion is a right-of-life to every baseball fan.
Building that opinion into a rock-solid reality is a work of art to the average fan.